What is happening between siti and jane

Pertanyaan

With a partner, read the conversational text given.

Siti: Why are you looking so sad?

Jane: I was reading an opinion article on bullying. It made me extremely sad.

Siti: Ah! People like to exaggerate things, bullying as a such is no big deal.

Jane: No, I don't think so. Bullying is prevalent in our society. It is important that eveeryone should be made aware of this social evil.

Siti: I don't agree with you. Little bit teasing here and there is acceptable.

Jane: I am of the opinion that no one has any right to harras or make people feel inferior. No one should have that kind of power.

Siti: Hey! Stop! You are getting too serious!

Jane: Yes! You should be serious about it as well. I would like to point out that bullying is everyone's problem and responsbility. If you condone bullying in any way, shape or form it means you are takeing part in whether it is directly or indirectly by being silent.

Discuss these questions with your partner.

1. What is happening between Siti and Jane?

2. what kind of conversations are they having?

3. whom do you agree with, Jane or siti? why?

4. have you witnessed bullying? describe how you felt.​

Answer ( jawaban ) :

1. Siti and Jane are having a conversation about bullying, and they have differing opinions on the matter. Jane is deeply affected by an opinion article she read about bullying and believes it is a serious issue that needs to be addressed by everyone. On the other hand, Siti seems to downplay the seriousness of bullying, suggesting that it is often exaggerated and that a little teasing is acceptable. This difference in viewpoints leads to a disagreement between them, with Jane insisting on the importance of taking bullying seriously and Siti dismissing it as not a big deal.

Here’s a detailed breakdown of what is happening:

Jane's Concern: Jane is visibly upset after reading an article about bullying, indicating that she finds the issue deeply troubling and believes it needs serious attention.

Siti's Dismissal: Siti dismisses Jane's concerns by stating that bullying is exaggerated and not a significant problem, implying that minor teasing is acceptable.

Jane's Argument: Jane argues that bullying is a prevalent societal issue and stresses that no one should have the power to harass or demean others. She believes everyone has a responsibility to address and prevent bullying.

Siti's Pushback: Siti thinks Jane is overreacting and takes the conversation too seriously.

Jane's Final Point: Jane emphasizes that ignoring or condoning bullying, even passively, makes one complicit in it. She tries to convince Siti that the issue is everyone's responsibility and should be taken seriously.

The conversation highlights a clash of perspectives on the gravity of bullying, with Jane advocating for awareness and action, while Siti minimizes the issue.

2. Siti and Jane are having a debate or argumentative conversation about the seriousness and impact of bullying. Their conversation is characterized by a few key elements:

Expressing Opinions: Both Siti and Jane express strong personal opinions on the topic of bullying. Jane believes bullying is a serious issue, while Siti thinks it is often exaggerated.

Disagreement: There is a clear disagreement between them. Jane views bullying as a significant societal problem that everyone should take seriously, whereas Siti considers it to be overemphasized and not a big deal.

Emotional Responses: The conversation is emotionally charged. Jane is visibly upset and passionate about the issue, while Siti is more dismissive and seems to be trying to lighten the mood.

Persuasion: Jane attempts to persuade Siti to take bullying more seriously and recognize its impact. She tries to convey the importance of collective responsibility in addressing bullying.

Clash of Perspectives: The conversation showcases a clash of perspectives, with Jane advocating for empathy and action against bullying, and Siti downplaying its significance.

Overall, the conversation is a classic example of a debate where two people have differing views on an important social issue and try to convince each other of their respective viewpoints.

3. Jane's perspective seems more aligned with a widely accepted understanding of bullying. She emphasizes the seriousness of the issue, highlighting its prevalence in society and the harm it can cause to individuals. Furthermore, she emphasizes the importance of collective responsibility in addressing bullying, asserting that it is everyone's problem.

On the other hand, Siti appears to downplay the seriousness of bullying, suggesting that it is often exaggerated and not a significant concern. She even implies that some level of teasing is acceptable.

Considering these viewpoints, I would lean towards agreeing with Jane. Bullying is indeed a serious societal issue that can have long-lasting effects on individuals' mental and emotional well-being. Ignoring or minimizing its impact only perpetuates the problem and can lead to further harm. Therefore, advocating for awareness, prevention, and intervention, as Jane does, seems to be the more responsible and compassionate approach.

4. Yes, I have. I feel so sad seeing that.

Catatan :

berikut terjemahan dari percakapan diatas:

Siti : Kenapa kamu terlihat sangat sedih?

Jane: Saya sedang membaca artikel opini tentang bullying. Itu membuatku sangat sedih.

Siti : Ah! Orang suka membesar-besarkan sesuatu, bully itu bukan masalah besar.

Jane: Tidak. Saya rasa tidak. Bullying adalah hal yang lazim di masyarakat kita. Adalah penting bahwa setiap orang harus disadarkan akan kejahatan sosial ini.

Siti: Saya tidak setuju dengan Anda. Sedikit menggoda di sana-sini dapat diterima.

Jane: Saya berpendapat bahwa tidak ada yang berhak melecehkan atau membuat orang merasa rendah diri. Seharusnya tidak ada yang memiliki kekuatan seperti itu.

Siti : Hei! Berhenti! Anda menjadi terlalu serius!

Jane: Ya! Anda juga harus serius tentang hal itu. Saya ingin menunjukkan bahwa bullying adalah masalah dan tanggung jawab semua orang. Jika Anda memaafkan bullying dengan cara, bentuk, atau bentuk apa pun, itu berarti Anda ikut serta di dalamnya baik secara langsung maupun tidak langsung dengan diam.